What good am I if I’m like all the rest,
If I just turned away, when I see how you’re dressed,
If I shut myself off so I can’t hear you cry,
What good am I?
— Bob Dylan, “What Good Am I?“
In one of my earliest posts last February, Dylan’s probing question led me to confess that I lacked a good personal response to the homeless people I meet every day on the streets of Berkeley.
I’m not sure I’ve formulated any better answers after a year, but I have tried to be more helpful, more bold, more compassionate. Most of the time, though, I fall far short of anything remotely resembling loving generosity.
One suggestion that Kevin offered at the time was that I should keep a few fast food gift certificates in my pocket so I could offer something tangible to someone who said they needed a meal.
That’s a suggestion that I never acted on. Until yesterday, that is.
Well, sort of.
As I was walking to grab some lunch, I was not surprised to be approached by a homeless person. But this bedraggled older man started things off a bit unexpectedly:
“Do you eat at McDonald’s?” he asked.
“Um, not usually,” I replied. “Why do you ask?”
He thrust a set of McDonald’s gift certificates towards me. I thought that perhaps he was afraid to go into the store to redeem them. I’ve known other homeless folks who’ve been treated pretty shabbily by local restaurants, so I could understand why that might be the case. So I asked him if he’d like me to go into McDonald’s to buy him some lunch.
He answered quickly, as if he feared that any pause in his speech would give me an opportunity to exit stage right: “No, sir. I was actually hoping that you’d buy these certificates from me. I don’t like McDonald’s, so I don’t have much use for these. What I’d really like is to get me a big ol’ chili dog.”
As much as I hate to admit it, all the old suspicions tumbled back into my head…. Someone gave him these certificates as a gift, isn’t he being ungrateful? What if he wants to use the money for whatever his destructive habit of choice might be? Why isn’t McDonald’s good enough for someone who’s hungry?
Shameful, really.
The thing is, I don’t like McDonald’s either. How could I fault him for sharing my distaste? And while I’ve certainly known people whose lives were ripped apart by alcohol or crack, what did it say about me that I assumed something similar about the life of this man? Was I willing to make such a dignity-robbing assumption just because he was poor and black?
Hell, maybe the dude just wanted a chili dog.
If I wasn’t pounding away at a deadline at work, maybe I would have bought him that chili dog. Maybe I would have sat and eaten lunch with him. Maybe I would have learned something from him. Even if it was only his name.
Waiter, do you have a table for two dim reflections of the imago dei?
In the end, I bought the certificates from him and gave him a buck or two extra. I wished him well and sent him off to his chili dog or who-the-hell-knows-what-else with a smile.
I guess it was the least I could do.
And now I’ve got some McDonald’s gift certificates to give to the next person who tells me that he’s hungry.